This article describes how one simple activity, which is called one-minute paper, can improve students' learning and active participation in class. It also reports a pilot project to show the positive effect of using one-minute paper in university classes.
What is one-minute paper?
It is a modest, relatively simple and low-tech innovation designed to obtain
regular feedback from students. In the final minute or two of class, the teacher
asks students to respond to the following two questions:
1. What is the most important thing you learned today?
2. What is the muddiest point still remaining at the conclusion of today's class?
Before leaving the classroom every lesson, students drop their one-minute papers
into a box located near the exit of the classroom. Teachers then take a look
at them after every class.
What are the objectives of these two questions?
The first question directs students to focus on the big picture, that is, what
is being learned, whereas the second seeks to determine how well learning is
proceeding.
What are the advantages of using one-minute paper?
Evidence of good effect of using one-minute paper
Author conducted a pilot project in which authors used the one-minute paper
to augment instruction in introductory economics courses in three semesters.
They used a control versus experimental group research design. In the project,
four different instructors each taught control and experimental sections of
the microportion of the principles of economics course identically except for
the introduction of the one-minute paper into the experimental section. Relevant
data collected from the project were used to run regression (If you are interested
in the regression model used in the analysis, you can refer to the paper at:
http://www.indiana.edu/%7Eeconed/pdffiles/winter98/chizmar.pdf.) Finally, the
results of regression suggest that one-minute paper does enhance economic knowledge.
Also, the results show that the effect of the one-minute paper on students'
economic knowledge varies little across instructors and does not depend on the
student's ability level.